The Best Omakase-Only Restaurants In Austin 2024 - Austin - The Infatuation (2024)

photo credit: Richard Casteel

If you’re looking to blow through a ton of money in a short period of time, well, first let us tell you about a great multi-level investment opportunity. Next, let us tell you about Austin’s recent boom in high-end omakase meals. Austin has a lot of great sushi restaurants, and ordering an omakase (chef’s choice) menu has long been an option at many of them. But recently there’s been a massive influx of highly exclusive and semi-secret spots offering omakase-only menus. Reservations at many of them are difficult to come by, and they tend to get scooped up faster than tickets to a Taylor Swift concert. Expect to spend anywhere from $100 to $300 per person at each of these spots on the base menu. Most offer additional bites at the end (generally ranging from about $20-80 if you try them all) plus whatever drink pairing or bottle of sake you decide to go with. It can add up quickly. Here are all the omakase-only spots in Austin, ranked.

THE SPOTS

Reservations at all of Austin’s omakase spots right now are tough to come across. But none, perhaps, are as tough to get as Tsuke Edomae, a tiny sushi bar in Mueller that gets booked out months in advance. It’s a bare-bones space, with a small, minimalist sushi counter with eight seats, each with a slate and an Hermès bowl that costs more than your entire meal. Expect a few small plates, plus 8-10 pieces ofclassic Edomae-style sushi. This is nigiri in its simplest form—with most dressed in nothing but soy sauce and wasabi—and sets the gold standard in Austin for sushi purists.

Cost: $135 per person, with optional add-ons. Sake pairing available.

This sleek Rosedale spot should be the poster child for omakases that want to break a little from tradition. Fish is the star of the show here—with most pieces undergoing some level of curing, dry-aging, or probably yoga to bring out different textures and flavors—and the garnishes are accents instead of the maximalist limelight hoggers you might find somewhere like Sushi Bar. The small plates served between every few bites of nigiri are where things veer a little from the classic omakase format, adding in global flavors without turning the whole meal into some forced fusion that relies on novelty. There are no upsells at the end, and no extra bites—you won’t need them, anyway. The whole experience feels less like a meal and more like a delicious 22-point justification for why someone might pay $175 for sushi.

Cost: $175 per person, no add-ons available. Sake and wine pairings available.

Otoko is often considered one of the swankiest restaurants in Austin, with a price tag that shows they’re clearly aware. It’s a place to dress up a little and feel like a rock star, as you watch the chefs prepare your meal in a room that’s basically a tunnel of light to a soundtrack of Bowie, Sun Ra, and Fugazi, with a chef that looks like he could have just hopped off any of their stages. There are three menus here that change based on what day you show up (and pre-book). Most days it’s a kaiseki menu—a mix of seasonal vegetables and nigiri—but there’s also a weekly mostly sushi night, and a shorter, slightly cheaper menu on Tuesdays and the first Thursday of the month. This is a place we would reserve for special occasions—anniversaries, promotions, and birthdays—but a meal here will turn even the blandest of weekdays into a special occasion of its own.

Cost: $200-$250 per person. $150 shortened menu available on the first Thursday of the month. Sake, wine, shochu pairings available.

Toshokan is a small, six-seat omakase behind a secret bookshelf at a mini golf course in East Austin. First, take a second to unpack that sentence. Second, set your timer for the first of the month, because that’s when tickets to these dinners go live, and to say they go fast is an understatement. Dinner is about 14 courses, and it very much falls in the realm of new-school nigiri—the chef is a Sushi Bar alum—but what sets Toshokan apart from some of the others is that they never forget that the fish is ultimately the star of the show. Well, that and the fact that the tiny dining room feels like you’re eating in Harry Potter’s cupboard under the stairs, if it had been decorated with a live edge sushi bar and cute Japanese toys on the walls.

Cost: $150 per person, with optional add-ons. Sake pairing available.

Tare follows the same format as a lot of the other spots on this list—a speakeasy-style dining room and 15-ish courses of nigiri and small plates. But instead of looking like an expensive carbon copy, Tare feels like it spent its formative years in the Rio Grande Valley and decided to mix in everything around it. Nigiri ranges from minimalist bites touched with nothing but soy and wasabi over well-seasoned rice, to a few more experimental ones like shima aji drizzled with salsa macha, or sweet shrimp served raw over a bite-sized tamale. It’s a little bit Japanese, and a little bit South Texan, and it somehow all takes place at a 12-seat sushi counter hidden behind a curtain in a nondescript office building in North Austin.

Cost: $135 per person, with optional add-ons. Sake pairings available.

This is where things start to get confusing. The folks that originally founded Sushi Bar in Austin sold the name and started a new concept out in the middle of nowhere (OK, it’s at the Lost Pines Resort close to Bastrop), in a hotel that feels a little like a haunted old Hill Country estate. It’s an odd backdrop for an omakase, but if anything it speaks to the more elusive, speakeasy nature of the 16-18 course dinner here. While you can expect a few pieces of classic sushi, you’ll also find a lot of bites like torched whelk nigiri topped with beet mustard, lemon juice, and quinoa. It’s not traditional at all, but it’s not really trying to be. If you want the original pioneers in “new-wave nigiri” (their words), this is where you’ll want to head.

Cost: $165 per person, with optional add-ons. Sake pairing and general beverage pairing (a mix of sake, beer, wine, and co*cktails) available.

.

For a while, Uroko in Springdale General in East Austin had a secret identity situation going on. By day it was a casual handroll spot, and at night it operated as an intimate omakase experience. Eventually, the owners took over the space next door and opened Tonari—an omakase-only sushi spot that never has to wear a disguise. Dinner here consists of 12 bites of nigiri served over 45 minutes, meaning you can snag one of the “1 hour limit” parking spots at the front of Springdale General and be out with time to spare. Tonari was started by some of the folks behind the sushi spot Komé—which we like very much—and as a result, a dinner here feels a lot like a quick, chef-curated meal at its older sibling. That means generous portions of fresh fish, and a minimalist, no-frills approach to nigiri. It also happens to be one of the most affordable omakase spots in town. Don’t come here to celebrate that big promotion or to finally propose to your partner of 15 years, just come here for good quality sushi that you don’t have to plan months in advance to eat

Cost: $84 per person. Sake flights available.